Skip to content
Community Will

Where the schools of law differ

The four Sunni schools agree on most inheritance rules. Here are the cases where they differ, and what to do if you are unsure.

3 min read

Your will divides your estate according to a madhab (school of Islamic law) that you choose: Hanafi, Shafi'i, Maliki or Hanbali. For most families all four schools give the same result. In a few well-known situations they do not, and the calculator applies the position of the school you pick.

The main differences

  • Grandfather with siblings. When the father has died but his father is alive, and the deceased has brothers or sisters, the Hanafi school says the grandfather excludes the siblings. The other schools follow the method of Zayd ibn Thabit, giving the grandfather the best of sharing with the siblings, a third or a sixth.
  • Mushtaraka (the shared case). In a particular family where the maternal siblings take a third and nothing is left for the full siblings, the Shafi'i and Maliki schools let the full siblings share the maternal siblings' third. The Hanafi and Hanbali schools give the full siblings nothing.
  • Paternal grandmother with the father. Most schools say the father excludes his own mother. The Hanbali school says she still inherits.
  • Radd (return of surplus). When fixed shares leave a surplus and there is no residuary heir, the surplus is returned to the fixed-share heirs other than the spouse. Classical Shafi'i and Maliki texts sent it to the public treasury; later scholars of those schools apply radd where no proper treasury exists, and the calculator applies radd for all schools with a note.

The schools also differ on debts owed to Allah, such as unpaid zakat or Hajj. Some treat them as debts paid before the wasiyyah (bequest of up to one third); others treat them as a bequest from the third. The will tells your executors to follow your school's teaching.

Your will does not fix the shares in advance. It leaves the residue to your heirs under your school at your death, and your executors get a written determination from a scholar or Shari'ah council. So a scholar of your school has the final word on these cases.

If you are unsure which school you follow

  1. Think about your family and community

    Many people follow the school of the masjid they attend or of the community they grew up in. Ask your parents or your imam which school they follow.

  2. Check whether it matters for you

    Run the calculator under different schools. If the shares come out the same, your choice makes no practical difference to your family today.

  3. Ask a scholar where it does

    If the result changes, speak to a scholar you trust before you choose. Your family may change, so the cases above can matter later even if they do not now.

  4. Name who will decide

    In the will, you can name the scholar, Shari'ah council or Islamic institution your executors should ask. If you leave it blank, your executors choose a qualified one.

Schools not yet covered

This service supports the four Sunni schools. Ja'fari (Shi'a) inheritance is not supported yet. Whatever school you follow, this is guidance, not a fatwa, so take a scholar's view where the stakes are high.

You can compare schools for your own family in the calculator at /calculator, and choose your school in the will builder at /write.